The national starting point
HomeAdvisor puts a full roof replacement at $5,903 to $13,380 nationally, averaging $9,611. Fixr's own figure runs $7,500 to $14,000, about $10,000 on average. Both cover a typical asphalt-shingle job before you factor in a specific material choice, roof size, or your own city's labor rate.[1],[2]
Per square foot, HomeAdvisor's range works out to about $4 to $11, averaging around $7, while Fixr's own per-square-foot figure runs $3.75 to $11, averaging $4.75. The gap between the two guides is a reminder that even national averages depend on how each one collected its data.[2],[3]
Asphalt: 3-tab versus architectural
A basic 3-tab asphalt shingle roof runs about $200 to $500 per square installed, according to HomeGuide. Architectural, or dimensional, shingles cost more per square, from roughly $400 to $600, since each shingle is a heavier, laminated product rather than a single flat tab.[4],[5]
Metal
Steel panel roofing, the most common metal option, runs about $6 to $16 per square foot installed, or roughly $600 to $1,600 per square, per HomeAdvisor's metal roofing cost data. Standing seam profiles and premium metals like copper price well above corrugated steel panels within that same guide.[6]
Tile and wood shake
Concrete tile installs for about $7 to $19 per square foot, roughly $700 to $1,900 per square, while clay tile runs higher, about $8 to $25 per square foot, or $800 to $2,500 per square, according to HomeGuide's separate cost pages for each material.[7],[8]
Wood shake sits at the top of this list, at roughly $25 to $30 per square foot installed, or $2,500 to $3,000 per square, per HomeGuide's cedar shake cost page.[9]
Why one material still shows a wide range
Even within a single material, the low and high end of each range usually reflect a builder-grade product against a premium line: a basic three-tab shingle against a heavier laminated one, or bare corrugated steel against a coated standing-seam panel. Brand, coating or color, wind and impact rating, and the manufacturer's own warranty length all sit inside that spread before labor is even added.
That's part of why this page pairs each material's national range with your city's own wage adjustment rather than printing one flat number: the material range and the labor range move for different reasons, and a quote should let you see both laid out separately rather than folded into a single total.