Paying outright
Cash skips interest, fees, and a lien entirely, which is why it's worth pricing against any financing offer before signing, even if the financed monthly number looks smaller on paper.
Borrowing against the house: HELOC or home equity loan
A home equity loan hands you the full amount at once and is repaid in fixed installments, at a fixed or adjustable rate. A HELOC works more like a credit card: you draw against an approved limit as needed, usually at a variable rate, and the available credit comes back as you repay it.[1]
The CFPB notes that either one is generally a second mortgage on top of whatever you already owe on the house, which is why a housing counselor is worth a call before you sign, not after.[1]
Contractor-arranged financing: check the APR, not the monthly payment
The APR folds the interest rate together with origination charges and other fees the lender adds at signing, which is why the CFPB recommends comparing APR to APR across offers rather than comparing one lender's interest rate to another's APR.[2]
A 'no interest if paid in full' promotion is a deferred-interest offer, and the word doing the work is 'if.' The CFPB warns that any balance left after the promotional period ends gets charged interest retroactively, back to the purchase date, not just on what's left owing.[3]
The minimum payment printed on a deferred-interest statement is usually not enough to clear the balance before the promotion ends, so working out your own payoff schedule in advance, and asking that anything above the minimum go toward that balance specifically, is the CFPB's own advice on these offers.[3]
A personal loan, without the lien
A personal installment loan hands you the full amount upfront and is repaid in fixed installments over a set term, the same shape as a home equity loan, per the CFPB's own description. The difference that matters most for a roof is collateral: a personal loan is typically unsecured, so it doesn't put the house itself on the line the way a home equity loan or HELOC does.[4]
When insurance pays for it instead
A storm or hail claim can cover a roof replacement where the damage is sudden and specific rather than ordinary wear. General guidance on filing that kind of claim starts with photographing the damage before any cleanup, reporting it to your carrier promptly, and getting your own contractor's estimate before the adjuster's visit so you have a second number to compare against theirs.[5]
The National Insurance Crime Bureau's storm-chaser warning applies here too: a legitimate insurer never asks for your deductible upfront or over the phone, and a contractor who offers to waive it, or who claims to be affiliated with your insurance company by name, is a reason to slow down and call the number on your own policy instead.[6]
Before you sign anything
The FTC warns that a contractor who shows up offering to arrange financing through 'a lender he knows' is a known scam pattern, one that often ends in a high-interest loan, blank paperwork, and a job that's paid for before it's finished. Shop financing independently of the contractor, and never sign a document with blank spaces or terms you haven't actually read.[7]
If you do sign contractor-arranged financing at your home, federal law generally gives you until midnight of the third business day after signing to cancel for a full refund, using the cancellation form the seller is required to give you. Mailing that form before the deadline, ideally by certified mail, is what makes the cancellation count.[8]