West Islip's top-rated roofing contractors, by the numbers

Quick answer

Who are the top-rated roofing contractors in West Islip, NY?

West Islip, NY lists 10 top-rated roofing contractors from a Google Maps search in and near the city. Stars and review counts were checked September 2026. A Google rating is not a license check.

HomeAdvisor reports a roof replacement at $5,903 to $13,380 nationwide[1],[2]

Updated

How we rank

Use the calculator above for West Islip's price range, then look at the 10 top-rated roofers listed below it. Together they average 4.9 stars on 909 Google reviews. A high rating says nothing about the quote you'll get, so treat the two sections of this page as separate questions.

Google Maps ratings checked · How we rank

Updated

Questions to ask before you compare bids

Does your price break out material, labor, tear-off, and permit fees as separate lines?

A rating is not a license.

What roof size in squares did you measure, and can I see how you got that number?

Open the Google reviews link.

Is this a price for a recover, or a full tear-off down to the deck?

This rank is not an endorsement.

What's your rate if you find damaged decking once the old roof comes off?

Ask for a license number.

Is the ice-and-water barrier at the eaves and valleys included, or priced separately?

Stars on this page were checked.

More on New York →

Estimated cost in West Islip

Estimated cost in West Islip, NY
ProjectNational rangeWest Islip estimate
20-square 3-tab asphalt roof$4,000 to $10,000$4,900 to $12,300
20-square architectural asphalt roof with a tear-off$9,000 to $15,000$11,000 to $18,400
20-square architectural roof, tear-off plus new decking$13,000 to $31,000$16,000 to $38,000
30-square metal roof with a tear-off$19,500 to $52,500$23,900 to $64,400
25-square concrete or clay tile roof with a tear-off$18,800 to $66,300$23,000 to $81,300
20-square wood shake roof with an ice-and-water barrier$50,200 to $60,400$61,600 to $74,100

The West Islip column follows New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ roofer pay up or down, applied to the roughly 60% of a replacement price that goes to labor.[4] Build your own estimate →

$36.73 median hourly wage for roofers in the metro

What roofers earn near West Islip, NY

The $36.73 hourly figure behind West Islip's estimate comes from the same federal wage survey used for every city on this site.

It runs 38% above the $26.65 national median.

That's the one local variable in West Islip's otherwise national price range.

U.S. median $26.65/hr

Data: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics (OEWS), May 2025.

1960 median year homes were built

About West Islip's housing stock

26,865 people live in West Islip, where 95% of occupied homes are owner-occupied rather than rented.

Owners, not landlords, are usually the ones budgeting for what's over their heads in West Islip.

This calculator is built around West Islip's owners, not a rental-market estimate.

Data: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates, table-based Summary File (2024 table-based Summary File).

Top-rated roofing contractors near West Islip, NY

The order above weighs each Google rating by its review count, strongest first; it isn't a license check and it isn't part of the price math.

  1. ML Best ConstructionRoofing contractor · 5.0 out of 5 on Google · 313 Google reviews · Wyandanch 11798Google reviews
  2. Advanced RoofingRoofing contractor · 5.0 out of 5 on Google · 68 Google reviews · West Babylon 11704Google reviews
  3. Roof ProRoofing contractor · 5.0 out of 5 on Google · 59 Google reviews · Bay Shore 11706Google reviews
  4. J. Great RoofingRoofing contractor · 4.9 out of 5 on Google · 168 Google reviews · West Babylon 11704Google reviews
  5. Premium Roofing & SidingRoofing contractor · 5.0 out of 5 on Google · 42 Google reviews · Bay Shore 11706Google reviews
  6. Tony the RooferRoofing contractor · 5.0 out of 5 on Google · 42 Google reviews · Bay Shore 11706Google reviews
  7. Clearview Roofing & Construction BabylonRoofing contractor · 4.9 out of 5 on Google · 53 Google reviews · Babylon 11702Google reviews
  8. Shingle It Two Roofing, Siding, & MoreRoofing contractor · 4.9 out of 5 on Google · 32 Google reviews · Babylon 11702Google reviews
  9. LaRocco Roofing & SidingRoofing contractor · 5.0 out of 5 on Google · 20 Google reviews · Not listedGoogle reviews
  10. D & S Roofing Corp.Roofing contractor · 4.7 out of 5 on Google · 112 Google reviews · Deer Park 11729Google reviews

20-square 3-tab asphalt roof: nearby cities

Sources

  1. How Much Does Roof Replacement Cost in 2025?, HomeAdvisor, accessed 2026-11-11
  2. How Much Does a Roof Replacement Cost? [2026 Data], Fixr, accessed 2026-09-30
  3. How Much Does an Asphalt Shingle Roof Cost? (2026), HomeGuide, accessed 2026-09-30
  4. How Much Does a Metal Roof Cost in 2026?, HomeAdvisor, accessed 2026-11-12
  5. Roofers: Occupational Outlook Handbook, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, accessed 2026-09-30