Oyster Bay's top-rated roofing contractors, by the numbers

Quick answer

Who are the top-rated roofing contractors in Oyster Bay, NY?

Oyster Bay, NY lists 8 top-rated roofing contractors from a Google Maps search in and near the city. Stars and review counts were checked September 2026. A Google rating is not a license check.

HomeAdvisor reports a roof replacement at $5,903 to $13,380 nationwide[1],[2]

Updated

How we rank

Use the calculator above for Oyster Bay's price range, then look at the 8 top-rated roofers listed below it. Together they average 4.5 stars on 410 Google reviews. A high rating says nothing about the quote you'll get, so treat the two sections of this page as separate questions.

Google Maps ratings checked · How we rank

Updated

Questions to ask before you compare bids

Does your price break out material, labor, tear-off, and permit fees as separate lines?

A rating is not a license.

What roof size in squares did you measure, and can I see how you got that number?

Open the Google reviews link.

Is this a price for a recover, or a full tear-off down to the deck?

This rank is not an endorsement.

What's your rate if you find damaged decking once the old roof comes off?

Ask for a license number.

Is the ice-and-water barrier at the eaves and valleys included, or priced separately?

Stars on this page were checked.

More on New York →

Estimated cost in Oyster Bay

Estimated cost in Oyster Bay, NY
ProjectNational rangeOyster Bay estimate
20-square 3-tab asphalt roof$4,000 to $10,000$4,900 to $12,300
20-square architectural asphalt roof with a tear-off$9,000 to $15,000$11,000 to $18,400
20-square architectural roof, tear-off plus new decking$13,000 to $31,000$16,000 to $38,000
30-square metal roof with a tear-off$19,500 to $52,500$23,900 to $64,400
25-square concrete or clay tile roof with a tear-off$18,800 to $66,300$23,000 to $81,300
20-square wood shake roof with an ice-and-water barrier$50,200 to $60,400$61,600 to $74,100

The Oyster Bay column follows New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ roofer pay up or down, applied to the roughly 60% of a replacement price that goes to labor.[4] Build your own estimate →

$36.73 median hourly wage for roofers in the metro

What roofers earn near Oyster Bay, NY

Roofers working near Oyster Bay earn a median $36.73 an hour, based on the metro wage data behind this page's estimate.

That runs 38% above the $26.65 national median for the same occupation.

The calculator above already applies that gap to Oyster Bay's numbers.

U.S. median $26.65/hr

Data: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics (OEWS), May 2025.

1957 median year homes were built

About Oyster Bay's housing stock

Homes in Oyster Bay have a median build year of 1957, per Census Bureau estimates.

86% of the housing stock predates 1980, old enough to already be on a second or third roof.

Run one of Oyster Bay's older roofs through the calculator above with its own size and material.

Data: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates, table-based Summary File (2024 table-based Summary File).

Top-rated roofing contractors near Oyster Bay, NY

The order above weighs each Google rating by its review count, strongest first; it isn't a license check and it isn't part of the price math.

  1. Atlantic Exteriors Inc.Roofing contractor · 5.0 out of 5 on Google · 133 Google reviews · Farmingdale 11735Google reviews
  2. Elite Waterproofing & RoofingRoofing contractor · 5.0 out of 5 on Google · 86 Google reviews · Glen Cove 11542Google reviews
  3. L.I.N.Y. ROOFING LLC.Roofing contractor · 4.9 out of 5 on Google · 79 Google reviews · Glen Cove 11542Google reviews
  4. MK BEST ROOFINGRoofing contractor · 4.9 out of 5 on Google · 70 Google reviews · Roosevelt 11575Google reviews
  5. Nassau Roofing & RemodelingRoofing contractor · 5.0 out of 5 on Google · 17 Google reviews · Westbury 11590Google reviews
  6. Rapid RoofingRoofing contractor · 4.7 out of 5 on Google · 16 Google reviews · Syosset 11791Google reviews
  7. TL ContractingRoofing contractor · 4.3 out of 5 on Google · 6 Google reviews · Oyster Bay 11771Google reviews
  8. Oyster Bay Roofing & Sheet Metal IncRoofing contractor · 2.3 out of 5 on Google · 3 Google reviews · Oyster Bay 11771Google reviews

20-square 3-tab asphalt roof: nearby cities

Sources

  1. How Much Does Roof Replacement Cost in 2025?, HomeAdvisor, accessed 2026-11-11
  2. How Much Does a Roof Replacement Cost? [2026 Data], Fixr, accessed 2026-09-30
  3. How Much Does an Asphalt Shingle Roof Cost? (2026), HomeGuide, accessed 2026-09-30
  4. How Much Does a Metal Roof Cost in 2026?, HomeAdvisor, accessed 2026-11-12
  5. Roofers: Occupational Outlook Handbook, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, accessed 2026-09-30